CDE project 6: The use and misuse of emotion. Section 5.5b: empathy-based design.

This summary is edited from Adam’s final dissertation. The full document is also included as part of CDE project 6.

Written by
SOFII
Added
September 06, 2018

Empathy-based design.

By Adam Willis.

‘If your cause can draw on such legitimate emotion it will successfully raise funds’ (Burnett, Relationship Fundraising, 2002, p.113).

Much of the charity sector’s graphic design is based around empathy, which means it uses text and image in a way to create an emotional connection with the viewer. The technique’s effectiveness is supported by Small and Verrochi’s research, which, as we’ve explored, shows that using ‘sad’ facial expressions in advertising almost doubles donation amounts compared to other expressions.

View original image
Figure 15: Red Cross Society poster (British Red Cross, 1915)

Case study: Red Cross Society poster (1915)

In order to raise money for wounded soldiers in World War I, Tom Purvis designed a poster for the Red Cross Society, which asked churches of all denominations to donate one day’s collection money (figure 15).

The poster’s red border is a simple tactic to draw attention and evoke urgency. The soldier, who is dominant in size — is softly illustrated, evoking a fragility that reflects his physical condition. Unlike some modern adverts where subjects are represented as needy victims, this soldier actually looks past the viewer — he’s not begging.

Purvis understood the poster's audience, which consisted mainly of families and friends of soldiers, who would most likely be worried about their loved ones. Purvis therefore attempts to create a soldier many could recognise; by covering his hair with a bandage this soldier could resemble most men. This strategy generates maximum potential empathy, and alongside the cursively written call to action ‘Help Him’, it's no wonder church members donated £85,000. 

Empathy-based design: analysis

The connection between the stimulation of empathy, and the chance of a donation being made, has been understood for some time by charities (Griffin et al, 1993). Sargeant and Jay wrote that 

‘to be truly effective the arousal of empathy must be powerful enough to overcome indifference and stimulate giving, but not so powerful that it becomes personally distressing to the donor’ (2004, p.101). 

As we shall briefly explore, this balance can be difficult to find. 

One hundred years on from Tom Purvis’s poster for the Red Cross Society, many charities use a similar strategy of empathy-based design. Figures 16 and 17 show Disaster Emergency Committee (DEC) posters, which habitually feature a subject in distress juxtaposed by bold text reading ‘PLEASE DONATE’. In analysis of DEC's Nepal earthquake appeal poster (figure 16), Burnett said,

‘[The subject does not] have eye contact with you, so he's reduced in context to being a passive participant. He's not looking out at you, saying, "do something''. A younger, more vulnerable person would work better in appeals’. 

When looked at in comparison with the Philippines poster (figure 17), one might agree. 

Figures 16 & 17. Nepal Earthquake poster, Philippines typhoon poster (Dec, 2013, 2015).

As previously explored, too much information in a design can confuse viewers, leading to an emotional disconnec­tion. However with empathy-based design, the opposite can be true: that too much emotion and not enough information can look untrustworthy. 

Go too far into this latter category and some may deem an advert to be ‘poverty porn' . As defined by Nonprofit Quarterly, poverty porn (or development porn) is ‘[...] using false or exaggerated images in donor appeals as a fundraising tactic’ (2015). 

Figure 18: This style of advert raised millions of pounds during the Ethiopian famine in the 1980s (DEC, 1984).

A formulaic example of poverty porn would feature photos of starving, skeletal children covered in flies (figure 18). The repetition of such adverts means some of the public instinctively look away (Larson, 1973, p.106). Yau writes, 

‘we owe it to those we serve to avoid sensationalising their pain. Bad enough that they had to face trauma and obstacles without us using them or their situation as case studies to leverage public guilt’ (2012).

Conversely, however, a research study by Breeze and Dean illustrated that some individuals a charity ‘served’ didn’t mind how they were represented. In the study, which was principally a discussion with participants who had been helped by a homeless charity, the following opinion was shared:

‘If the organisations haven’t got their money in the first place to help you then the whole system breaks down, really and truly. Just get the money, hook or crook, y’know?’ (Breeze and Dean, 2012, p.20).

Somewhat in agreement, Burnett writes in Relationship Fundraising

‘It is not the images or the use of emotion that are obscene [...] What is obscene, I believe, is switching off or turning over in the hope that by doing so the problem, as well as the emotive images, will go away’ (2002, p.112)

In this argument, Burnett defends empathy-based design, because although it has the potential to make someone uncomfortable, he believes it’s right to illustrate the reality of world issues and challenge the public to action. 

A responding point might be that consistently ‘sad’ imagery could give the impression that donations have no effect. Making adverts happier, however, could evoke the opposite: that all the problems have been solved. Burnett believes there is a balance to be found, charities must:

‘[ ... ] balance emotional impact with honesty and integrity’ (2002, p.124).

Similarly, Christian Aid’s visual identity guidelines read, 

‘We shouldn't compromise the dignity of our subjects but equally we shouldn't sanitise reality' (2013, p.30). 

Ken Burnett once overheard employees from a cancer research organisation complaining about the difficulty in marketing their cause: it’s so complex, it’s long term, it’s not guaranteed to work, etc. He replied with the following:

‘Cancer research is about all those things. But, it's also not really about any of those things. What is it about? It's about me getting more time to spend with the people that matter to me. It’s about my mother, or my father, or any of my friends’ (2015).

Empathy-based design can empower both the donor and the recipient, through use of accurate information, alongside emotive, yet genuine imagery (figure 19). Through telling the stories of those in need, instead of victimising them, and balancing progress with the action that’s still needed, charities can move collectively toward a more authentic standard of advertising. 

Figure 19: Example of an advert that empowers the donor and the recipient through empathy-based design. (White Collar Boxing, 2015)

You can read Adam’s full dissertation by clicking on the image below

About the author: SOFII

The SOFII collection aims to be the most comprehensive, best organised, and most inspiring collection of fundraising related content from around the world.

Related case studies or articles

CDE project 6 section 1a: summary

Fundraising is inevitably emotional and emotion is hugely powerful, so must be used responsibly and wisely.

Read more

CDE project 6 section 6: the future

What will the future hold for emotional fundraising?

Read more

CDE project 6 section 1b: introduction.

Fundraisers need to get better at how they use emotion. And to take care that they don’t misuse it too. That’s what this project is all about.

Read more

CDE project 6 section 4: donors and emotion.

Selected articles exploring the role and impact of emotion on the donor experience.

This section is part of the Commission on the Donor Experience's project 6, the use and misuse of emotion. For the other sections and a detailed list of contents please click here.

Read more

CDE project 6 the full contents and purpose

Here you will find the full contents for all sections of CDE project 6 so you can learn everything about the use and misuse of emotion in fundraising.

Read more

CDE project 6 section 3: the science of emotions

Fundraising experts look at the science of emotions and how it can be applied to good fundraising.

Read more

CDE project 6. Section 5.2: the starfish story

A poignant little story about a man saving starfish reflects the emotional driving force of Robbie Macmillan's Children of Rwanda charity.

Read more

CDE project 6 section 3.4: emotional intelligence

Being more emotionally connected to each other on fundraising teams is more rewarding. And, being more emotionally open and connected to our donors raises more money.

Read more

CDE project 6 section 5: creative use of emotion.

Emotion is a powerful factor in good fundraising. Here some creative experts explore how the use it in practice.

Read more

CDE project 6. The emotional fundraising showcase

2.12. The emotional fundraising showcase video collection

Read more

CDE project 6 section 2: the emotional fundraising showcase

In part 2 of CDE’s project on the use and misuse of emotion we've collected some PowerPoint presentations, several articles and a series of videos that show aspects of emotional storytelling.

Read more

CDE project 6. Section 5.4b: the moody leader

In an extract from his book Storytelling can change the world, Ken Burnett looks at moody leaders from history and explores how emotion can play a part in strong leadership. 

Read more

CDE project 6. Section 4.9: to the edge of acceptability

In the latest addition to project 6 of the Commission on the Donor Experience, a harrowing and powerfully-written storyline on a BBC radio drama points to storytelling success for fundraisers.

Read more

CDE project 6 section 4.3: me the storyteller

The power of storytelling, and why every fundraiser should practice telling emotional stories.

Read more